Intro to Afro-American Studies
SIXTEEN
Marxism and Black Liberation
Toward a Paradigm of Unity in Afro-American Studies
LOGIC OF CHANGE | Social Cohesion | Traditional Africa | - | Slavery | - | Rural Life | - | Urban Life |
Social Disruption | - | Slave Trade | - | Emancipation | - | Migrations | - | |
UNITS OF ANALYSIS | Ideology | A1 | B1 | C1 | D1 | E1 | F1 | G1 |
Nationality | A2 | B2 | C2 | D2 | E2 | F2 | G2 | |
Class | A3 | B3 | C3 | D3 | E3 | F3 | G3 | |
Race | A4 | B4 | C4 | D4 | E4 | F4 | G4 |
Marxism is a social theory and a social movement based on an analysis of the
contradictions of the capitalist system. It is the science of the working
class. It also serves as the ideological basis for its revolutionary
struggle to destroy capitalism and replace it with socialism. Marxism as a
theory of history provides a theoretical explanation of how a society
develops. Further, as a science, Marxism guides research into the particular
details of how a specific society operates. This is crucial because while
Marxism has developed as an inclusive theory encompassing all available
research, it is always based on and revitalized by the use of what is known
in order to pursue and come to terms with what is unknown. |
319 | ||||||||||||||||
Two errors are made frequently by those who claim to be Marxists, but are not. Dogmatism refers to the error of holding a general theory and refusing to take into account particular details and historical conditions. The opposite error is empiricism. Empiricism holds onto specific concrete details and ignores previous knowledge that has been summed up in general theory. In general, Marxism stresses the unity of theory and practice, study and struggle. Practice is the primary aspect of the contradiction. Any study of Marxism thus must combine a study of the theory with the social practice of Marxist movements.
The
application of Marxism to Black liberation is both a theoretical and
practical task. As with any theory of social change, its usefulness can
only be fully proven with a successful revolution, led by a workers' party
guided by the ideology of Marxism. However, this does not free us from the
responsibility of taking up an analysis of how Marxism as theory treats
the problems faced by Black people; how Marxist movements in the U.S.A.
have handled these practical problems, especially building unity between
Black and white workers; and where the situation stands today.
The
United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)
has reported that the author whose books are read by more people in the
world than any other is V. I. Lenin, the leader of the 1917 Russian
Revolution. Moreover, the majority of people in the world are living in
societies who at, least "claim" to use Marxism. These are
some of the reasons we must study this question of Marxism in a very
serious way. INTERNATIONAL
MARXIST THEORY What is Marxism? It is the collective body of theory developed by Karl Marx (1818-1883) and Frederick Engels (1820-1895) in the period of revolutionary upheavals of the industrial working classes in Europe. They continued and developed the work of classical political economy from England (especially the work of Adam Smith and David Ricardo), classical German philosophy (especially George Wilhelm Hegel and Ludwig Feuerbach), and the utopian socialists from France (Saint-Simon and Franois Charles Fourier). The fundamental concepts of this body of thought include dialectical and historical materialism (which is a method for studying the dynamic change and development in nature and society); the labor theory of value and class struggle (which explains how labor's exploitation is the source of profits); and the dictatorship of the proletariat (which solves a society's basic problems by putting the masses of working people in power) In 1852, Marx commented on the particular contribution that he made through his studies: |
320 | ||||||||||||||||
The
major works of Marx and Engels include The Communist Manifesto, Civil
War in France, Capital, German Ideology, and Anti-Duhring.
The further development of the science of the working class was carried
out by Marxist theoreticians connected to the successful revolutionary
struggle waged in Russia in 1917. Led by V. I. Lenin (1870-1924), this
revolution, more than any other historical event, brought Marxism out of
the realm of theory and speculation into the realm of accomplished
historical fact. Lenin |
321 | ||||||||||||||||
The
next major advance was in China. The Marxist party was formed in 1921, and
twenty-eight years later the workers and peasants seized state (political)
power under the leadership of the revolutionary party and Mao Tse-Tung
(1893-1976). Mao made significant contributions to the application of
Marxism to China and to post-war developments within the international
Marxist movement. Mao developed and successfully applied the strategic
concept of the United Front in conjunction with the Peoples War. He also
was a major fighter for Marxist principles. He fought the errors of
dogmatism and empiricism (see his book Five Essays on Philosophy) and
made a major contribution in fighting revisionism during the Cultural
Revolution. More than any other event since the October
Revolution in Russia, the Chinese Revolution of 1949 brought dramatic
focus on how Marxism treats the national colonial question and the process
of national liberation struggles by oppressed nations - particularly in
Africa, Asia, and Latin America. There are two basic theoretical
ideas that identify the future Marxists are fighting for. Each is based on an exchange
between people, and the society as a whole. In other words, the key issue
for each person is: What am I supposed to do and what do I get for it in return? Communism - This is
the theory of "from each according to their ability, to each
according to their need." This is the ultimate view of human society
in which people are not pitted against each other in dog-eat-dog type
competition, but rather are organized for maximum cooperation. Each person
would be educated, cultured, and employed for their maximum contribution
to society. Further, each person would get what they need, based on the
overall level of production and wealth in society. Socialism - This is
the theory of "from each according to their ability to each according
to their deed." This theory focuses on an equitable exchange - a fair
day's pay, for a fair day's work. This theory holds that the people in a
society must be in control, and not a small group of capitalists. But we
have to make a distinction between utopian socialists and scientific
socialists. The utopian socialists believe in the idea, but they have no
analysis of society that demonstrates who is going to produce the new
society, and on what specific principles it will be constructed. The
scientific socialists are Marxists who analyze the contradictions within
capitalist society and focus on the working class as the historical force
destined to produce the new society. Further, rooted in political economy,
specific laws of social development are
studied to design a plan to transform society into one based on
cooperation rather than competition. |
322 | ||||||||||||||||
This
distinction is critical. But the complexity of Marxism intensifies when
the issues of class and class struggle are joined with race and
nationality. This is called the national question. The
major Marxist definition of a nation was formulated by Joseph Stalin in
his 1913 work on "Marxism and the National Question":
However,
this cannot be applied dogmatically, since there are four different types
of historical experiences in the development of nations: (1) the
nation-states of western Europe, (2) the multi- national states of eastern
Europe, (3) the multi-national states of Asia, and (4) the colonial
nations created under imperialist domination in Asia, Africa, and Latin
America.
Further,
the political significance of national movements differs, depending on the
historical context in which it develops. The formation of nation-states
in western Europe was a progressive political accomplishment led by the
bourgeoisie. The bourgeois classes advanced their societies by
overthrowing feudalism. However, these same bourgeois classes developed
and became the oppressors of colonized peoples in the Third World.
Therefore, the political character of the nation-states of western Europe
was transformed into its opposite
from being positive to being negative. Each western bourgeoisie
helped create opposites in the Third World. The western bourgeois classes
created the colonial nations, out of which developed progressive national
liberation movements.
Lenin
was the major Marxist theoretician who analyzed this and developed a
revolutionary solution for colonized nations. His position was summarized
by Stalin in 1924:
|
323 | ||||||||||||||||
U.S.
MARXIST MOVEMENTS How
does this general summation of Marxist theory in the world context relate
to Black people and the struggle for Black liberation in the United
States? The historical experience of the Marxist movement in the
U.S.A. concerning the question of Black people is filled with errors of
all kinds, but it is also filled with shining examples of revolutionary
leadership. The United States is quite obviously an imperialist country in
which the imperialists control most publishing companies, the mass media,
and schools. It is usually only the negative side of the Marxist movement
that is reported. Therefore it is necessary to present both sides to clear
up this confusion and enable students of Afro-American Studies to have an
objective scientific grasp of these questions. This is the only way in
which we can see both the positive and negative lessons
to learn from the historical involvement of the Marxist movement in the
Afro-American national question. (The "Afro-
American national question" refers to the relationship between the
struggle against exploitation of all workers and the struggle against the
oppression of Black people.) |
324 | ||||||||||||||||
However,
not all socialists agreed with this. The utopian socialists who followed
Robert Owen (1771-1858) and Charles Fourier (1772- 1837) set up
experimental model communities before the Civil War and they all
segregated Black people. Moreover, they incorrectly pushed the abolition
of slavery to the background in order to take up the struggle against the
wage slavery of workers in the North. On the other hand, the Marxists, led
by Joseph Weydemeyer (1818-1866) a close associate of Marx, set up
Communist Clubs with a constitution recognizing the complete equality of
all people regardless of sex or color. Many members of these clubs fought
actively in the Civil War.
After
the Civil War, however, the Marxist movement lost sight of Black people in
the U.S.A. In 1864, Marx led the formation of the first international
workers' organization, the International Working-Men's Association (IWA).
At its founding convention, the Colored National Labor Union (CNLU) voted to send a delegate to the IWA.
While all other labor organizations were invited to the 1870 congress of
the IWA, the CNLU was not invited. The IWA had nothing to say about the
problems of Blacks in the United States, although the U.S.A. was one of
their main subjects of discussion. The IWA moved to the United States in
1872 where it remained until 1876 when it was dissolved. The main IWA
leader in the United States, Friedrich Sorge, was noticeably silent on the
question of Black people. In his book Socialism and the Worker, written
in 1876 as Reconstruction was being wiped out with a wave of racist
reaction, there is not one mention of Black people. On the other hand, it was also during this period that the first Black socialists emerged. Peter H. Clark, born in 1829, was a socialist speaker of the Workingmen's Party at a 1877 rally to support the national railroad workers strike. Clearly articulating his socialist views, he declared: |
325 | ||||||||||||||||
As
the principal of the Black high school in Cincinnati, he was threatened
with the loss of his job if he didn't reject socialism. Nonetheless, he
continued his political work. When the Workingmen's Party was
transformed into the Socialist Labor Party, Clark remained within the
party. Eventually, in 1879, he left the party, not because he had lost
faith in socialism, but because he was dissatisfied with the party's
treatment of the problems facing Black people.
After
the turn of the century, especially after the October Revolution in 1917,
part of the socialist movement began moving into the transition to a
Communist party. In 1919, two parties were formed and when they merged in
1921, the Communist movement was born. The initial organizations did not
have a correct analysis and program for Black people, and thus did not
recruit very many Blacks.
Cyril
Briggs (1888-1966) was one of the first Black people to join the Communist
Party. Briggs was from the West Indies and had been involved in the left
wing of the Garvey movement. Briggs believed that the liberation of Black
people had to involve the formation of an independent Black, state, and
his idealism led him to
various pan-Africanist, back-to-Africa schemes. Inspired by the October
Revolution and the position Lenin developed on the national-colonial
question, Briggs in 1917 had formed a revolutionary Black nationalist,
pan-Africanist organization, the African Blood Brotherhood (ABB). |
326 | ||||||||||||||||
The
ABB had sought the following:
It
specifically had called for armed resistance to lynching and
self-determination in states where Blacks were a majority. At its height,
it had about 2,500 members in fifty-six chapters. During the 1920s, most
of the leaders of the ABB (including Briggs, Richard Moore, Otto Hall, and
Harry Haywood) joined the Communist Party, U.S.A. (CP-USA). They helped
formulate what became known as the Black Belt Nation thesis.
The
Communist Party faced a difficult situation in the United States during
the 1920s. Black people were being mobilized under the banner of Black
nationalism into the Garvey movement, and the class-struggle line that was
mechanically applied by the CP- USA did not speak to the special problems
that Black people faced. In fact, many communists negated the importance
of racism and other forms of the special oppression of Black people. They
dealt with the problems as if they were no different from the problems of
whites. They assumed that the solutions to these problems required no
special program.
.
With
the direct involvement of Blacks from the CP-USA, the Comintern developed
a revolutionary position on solving the problem of the oppression of Black
people, Its position was summed up in two resolutions passed during
1928 and 1930. The essence of the new position was to recognize Black
people as an oppressed nation. |
327 | ||||||||||||||||
Second,
it proposed establishing a single political entity - a state and a
government - to encompass those areas where Black people were in the
majority (which in 1930 included 190 countries in 12 states and 50% of the
U.S. Black population). The Comintern reported:
Third,
the Comintern upheld the right of self-determination, the
"right of the Negro majority to exercise governmental authority in
the entire territory of the Black Belt. . . " According to it's
analysis, "the right of self-determination of the Negroes as the main
slogan of the- Communist Party in the Black Belt is appropriate!'
From the Comintern's perspective, "The slogan of the right of
self-determination occupies the central place in the liberation struggle
of the Negro population in the Black Belt against the yoke of American
imperialism" |
328 | ||||||||||||||||
The
Comintern also made clear the nature of its commitment to Blacks outside
the rural Black Belt South:
More pointedly, it declared that "it is essential for the Communist Party to make an energetic beginning now - at the present moment - with the organization of joint mass struggles of white and Black workers against Negro oppression." , It was on the basis of this program that the CP-USA actively sought to carry out Lenin's 1920 instruction to the Comintern that revolutionaries should "render direct aid to the revolutionary movements among the dependent and subject nations (for ex- ample, in Ireland, among the Negroes of America, etc.)." As a result, the work of the Party was more effective and many Black people joined. From 200 members in March 1929, Black membership increased to over 1,300 by March 1930. This reflected the appeal of the Party's revolutionary political line on the struggle for Black liberation, the impact of the economic crisis of the Great Depression on Black people, and the militant revolutionary actions that the Party carried out among the masses, including Black people. A major battle field for the Party's work was in the South where 73% of Black people lived in 1930, mostly in rural areas. This work centered on sharecroppers, tenant farmers, and general racist terror, like the Ku Klux Klan and lynching. In 1931, the Sharecroppers Union was organized in Alabama under Communist Party leadership. By 1936, membership had reached 12,000 with branches in Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and North Carolina. In Arkansas, the Party led Black and white sharecroppers to force local planters and merchants to give them food. They fought for an emergency program calling for a 50% reduction in rents and taxes, a five-year moratorium on all debts and mortgages, and a cash advance from the government for all small farmers.
|
329 | ||||||||||||||||
The
greatest struggle that the Communist Party carried out in the South was
the fight to save the Scottsboro boys. Nine Black youths were charged with
raping two white women, a charge that one of the women later admitted she
was forced to make. All were quickly tried, convicted, and eight were
sentenced to die in the electric chair. For four years, the Party joined
with the NAACP, the American Civil Liberties Union, and others in waging
an international battle which saved them from the death penalty and later
resulted in their release.
Another
major organization during that period was the Southern Negro Youth
Congress, organized in 1937 at a conference in Richmond, Virginia. The
first conference was broad-based. It included representatives from nearly
every Black college in the country, young steelworkers from Birmingham,
sharecroppers, boy and girl scouts, churches, and even the YMCA. It was
formed in an era of the fascist menace. This concern for a united front
against fascism is reflected in an address by Dr. Mordecai Johnson, who
served over thirty years as the first Black president of Howard
University. He stated: "The greatest danger to democracy is not
'Communism or Socialism but first of all Fascism. A danger not only to
black but to white men." The conference endorsed a "Proclamation
of Southern Negro Youth" that spoke to the national, democratic
character of the movement:
|
330 | ||||||||||||||||
In
the North, the struggle for democratic rights centered on organizing
employed and unemployed workers, especially during the Depression. Black
workers were very prominent in cities throughout the United States. Over
1.3 million workers turned out for a massive national unemployment
demonstration in 1930. The National
Unemployed Councils were organized by the Communist Party in 1930 with
local chapters in many U.S. cities. The councils fought for unemployment
insurance, public work at union wages, and food for school children. They
also fought against home eviction and racial discrimination. Over 400,000
people were mobilized on National Unemployment Insurance Day in 1932, and
several thousands marched in hunger marches organized by the councils. The
U.S. ruling class was forced to establish programs like unemployment
insurance as a result of these mass struggles. For
those workers who had jobs, the formation of the Committee for Industrial
Organizations (CIO) in 1935 was significant. This union was a break with
the policies of the American Federation of Labor (AFL) which excluded
unskilled, Black, and women workers (see Chapter 7). The CIO had a
decisive impact on the unionization of Black workers in such industries as
auto, steel, and meatpacking. In 1930, there were an estimated 100,000
Black union members. By 1950, this had increased to 1.5 million, half in
the CIO and half in the AFL, which did not accept Black workers until the
CIO was organized. The Communist Party played a prominent role in the
formation and growth of the CIO, as William Z. Foster points out in his
study of trade unionism:
In
addition, the Communist Party assumed a leading role in establishing other
organizations which fought for Black liberation. For example, the National
Negro Congress, organized in 1936, was a broad, united-front organization
mainly but not exclusively comprised of Blacks from many different sectors
of the society. The Congress condemned racist discrimination, demanded
full rights for Black people, spoke out against fascism and,. war, and
played an active role in organizing Black workers into unions like the
CIO. (See Chapter 7 for additional discussion
of the CIO and the National Negro Congress.)
|
331 | ||||||||||||||||
However,
the revolutionary line and practice of the CP-USA turned into its
opposite. Black people were betrayed by the CP- USA in several ways. The
high points of building broad unity in mass organizations were marred by
the Party cadre's dominating leadership roles. For example, out of 86
leadership positions in the League of Struggle for Negro Rights formed
in 1930, the Party accounted for 62 (72%).
There
was also considerable racism among the Party rank-and- file membership.
The extent to which the Party was concerned about this can be seen in the
case of August Yokinen. Yokinen, a Finnish immigrant and a member of the
Party, was publicly tried in 1931 in Harlem by a 14-person jury (7 Blacks
and 7 whites) selected by delegates from working-class organizations. He
was found guilty and expelled from the Party for having failed to come to
the rescue of several Black workers, who had gone to a dance at Finnish
Hall and had been threatened, and for having made racist remarks about
Black people. Though the trial revealed the Party's desire to deal with
its members' racism, it also exposed the interracial problems that
existed. From its inception in 1919 to 1935, the CP used such disciplinary
measures to deal with members who exhibited racist attitudes or did not
adhere to the, Party's position regarding race, but it became increasingly
lax during and after the war years.
The
worst betrayal of Black people took place in the late 1930s when Earl
Browder, the General Secretary of the CP-USA, led the Party down the path
of revisionism. In 1944, he actually disbanded the Communist Party and
formed the Communist Political Association, claiming that the goals of the
CP-USA had been reached because of "American exceptionalism".
Browderism
represented the incorrect view that the United States was a special place
(unlike any other) in which capitalism was enlightened and electoral
politics was a sufficient process for the working class to achieve its
aims. The Communist Political Association, as Wilson Record put it in his
study of the Communist Party, |
332 | ||||||||||||||||
Within a year, Browder was expelled for having abandoned the working class and Marxist theory, and the Party was reconstituted. The Party admitted its failure to struggle for the rights of Black people during the war years, but in the meanwhile it had lost much of its credibility among Black people. Moreover, by 1951 the entire work of the Party in the South was terminated. This was a capitulation to the ruling-class terror against Blacks in the Black Belt.
Overall,
the liquidation of a revolutionary position on the Afro-American national
question was part of a general process of degeneration into a non-Marxist
or revisionist stand. After Joseph Stalin (1879-1953), Lenin's successor,
died, a new group turned socialism around from within the Communist Party.
The national question, the focus on the particular problems of Black
people as an oppressed nation and Black liberation, was formally
liquidated at the 16th convention of the CP-USA in 1957.
Is
important to point out that this decision in 1957 was just three years
before the explosion of the sit-ins and a period of militant spontaneous
mass struggle. Because of the CP-USA's revisionism, the Civil Rights
Movement in the deep South had no revolutionary leadership, and it fell
under the leadership of petty-bourgeois (middle-class) reformist leaders.
The revisionist CP-USA fell behind this reformist civil rights leadership,
which led them into the arms of the liberals in the Democratic Party. At
the same time, the major Trotskyist organization (the Socialist Workers
Party) was slavishly following Black nationalism and did not contribute to
developing revolutionary politics in the Black liberation movement.
|
333 | ||||||||||||||||
A major revolutionary upsurge spread all over the world in the middle 1960s. France faced nationwide strikes by students and workers; Japan faced an upsurge of student and worker struggle; etc. The major event was the Great Proletarian cultural Revolution started in China in 1966, which stirred up the revolutionary feeling among young people all over the world. The United States was no exception. The Cultural Revolution represented the greatest effort yet in history to transform the superstructure of a society under socialism, and to fight attempts to defeat socialism from within and restore capitalism. In sum, the Cultural Revolution in China demonstrated that class struggle (and struggle against national oppression as well) exists under socialism and that either socialism will continue to win victories or it will be defeated. The major symbol of the first stage of the Cultural Revolution was the Red Book of the thoughts of Chairman Mao. This book had the weakness of substituting quotes for the full texts of Marxist theory as developed within the Chinese context by the Communist Party and Mao. But it had the strength of giving concrete expression to revolutionary theory. It spread among the masses like no previous publication project in history. In the United States, the Red Book was taken up by militant Black activists, some of whom later formed the Black Panther Party in northern California. In 1968, Mao reiterated his earlier recognition of the importance of the Black liberation movement in the worldwide struggle against imperialism and lent it his support:
Since
the Panthers, there have been two main lines of development of Marxism
in the Black liberation movement. Basically, Marxists came from the
factory or from the campus, but both grew out of the militant Black
nationalist revolt of the 1960s. The major organization connected with
Black workers that spread Marxism was the Black Workers' Congress (BWC).
In 1970, some former activists of SNCC and the League of Revolutionary
Black Workers (Detroit) formed the Black Workers Congress. In general, the
BWC maintained: |
334 | ||||||||||||||||
Moreover,
most thought that internationally "the Black masses must line up with
the heroic peoples of the world who have struck blow after blow at
imperialism. . . ." However, there were internal differences
concerning how this was to be accomplished. Thus, the EWC subsequently
split into several organizations, and many of the activists were recruited
into major multi-national Marxist organizations. While the BWC never
distinguished itself in any concrete campaigns of struggle, it represented
the greatest effort in recent history of organizing Black people in an
explicitly Marxist organization.
The
major organization which spread Marxism among Black youth (especially from
1972 to 1975) was the African Liberation Support Committee. ALSC was a
coalition of different organizations. Within the Black liberation
movement, it waged the most significant ideological and political struggle
over Marxism since the 1930s. The main struggle was against the idealism
of the pan-Africanist movement, and for the Consolidation of a strong
anti-imperialist stand under Black Marxist leadership. ,
The
overall struggle against the revisionism of the CP-USA has resulted in the
formation of several self-declared Marxist parties or national
organizations, all claiming to be the vanguard of the working class.
However, the working class is still characterized by spontaneity and trade
unionism (struggles of reforms); the national movements are still
dominated by petty-bourgeois (middle-class) nationalists; and the national
liberation support movement is dominated by liberals. Overall, there is
still a vacuum on the question of revolutionary Marxist theoretical
analysis of the U.S.A. The main errors that are being made are sectarianism
(walling oneself from the rest of the movement by proclaiming oneself
the most correct) and right opportunism (uncritically uniting with
everyone and refusing to fight for revolutionary unity on the basis of
revolutionary principles). In sum, the new Marxist movement is young,
and decisive events are yet to develop. |
335 | ||||||||||||||||
CURRENT
TASKS
The further development of Marxist theory and the concrete activity of the
Marxist movement regarding the question of Black liberation are central to
the overall process of revolutionary struggle in the U.S.A. There are
several key issues: Building
the United Front as the strategy for making revolutionary changes -
The United Front is a concept that is based on the unity of action
(fighting against the same enemy) of as many different groups (classes,
nationalities, etc.) as possible in the struggle against imperialism and
national oppression. Bill Epton in discussing the Black liberation
movement (BLM) further defines the United Front:
Overall
what is needed is more class analysis that uncovers the material basis for
different classes, and the political and ideological actions of the
different classes - both Black and white. Who is against U.S. imperialism
and who is with it? What evidence is there that proves it one way or the
other?
Building
the Black-white unity as the condition for a strong United Front,
particularly the unity of the working class -
While the history of the U.S.A. stinks with the vicious odor of racism and
national oppression, the most revolutionary movements have been created
by the unity of the Black and white masses in struggle, particularly in
the 1930s. The ruling class tries to hold this back in many ways, and each
of their schemes needs to be exposed. The backward character of
white racism and narrow Black nationalism needs to be exposed. Progressive
examples of unity need to be popularized. Concrete historical and
contemporary bases for this unity need to be fully explained. |
336 | ||||||||||||||||
The
Black Belt and the issue of self-determination - The historical
periodization of the Black experience requires both empirical and
theoretical analysis, particularly on the question of the national
character of Black people: Are Black people a nation? Is the fight for
Black liberation still rooted in the Black Belt South? If not, what is
the main demand of the Black liberation struggle? No slavish adherence to
the Comintern resolutions and no bowing to the spontaneity of the Black
struggle at any time can replace the application of Marxism to the
objective content of Black history to come up with a correct and
revolutionary line. This is a project of utmost importance.
The
relationship between the Black liberation struggle against U.S.
imperialism and the African revolution - The current developments in
southern Africa against white settler colonialism are fairly easy to
understand and unite people against. However, most of Africa is at a stage
where the situation is not so obvious. Blacks are running countries,
though many are still dominated by foreign powers. It is necessary to
continue studying Africa in the context of the entire international
situation. Black people in the United States give particular attention to
Africa. If there is no clarity on the situation, this will have a negative
effect on the Black liberation movement.
In
sum, Marxism is a theory and practice for revolutionary change. The past
contributions of Black people to the revolutionary struggle in the U.S.A.
are generally agreed upon. The potential in the future is even greater.
But our understanding of it needs to be deepened in order to have the
kind of united movement required for the current demands of the struggle
for Black liberation and social change. TOWARD
A SCIENTIFIC APPROACH TO BLACK LIBERATION The
theory of class struggle holds that the motivating force of history is the
class struggle. Classes are large groups of people united by common
interests based upon having the same relationship to the means of
production - land and technology. Some folks own the land and technology
(capitalists) while others must work for them in order to get wages to
live (workers). The class struggle is based on the irreconcilable conflict
between the capitalists efforts to maintain the highest level of
exploitation of the workers to reap profits, and the workers' struggle to
increase Wages and get better working conditions. Indeed, this class
struggle is the basis of all struggles in this type of society, because
the capitalists control all the institutions- (government, education, the
church, mass media, etc.), and these same institutions oppress, mistreat,
and brutalize the workers.
|
337 | ||||||||||||||||
The
capitalist mode of production has developed from its early stage of
competitive capitalism to its mature stage of monopoly capitalism. This is
the transition from many small capitalist firms to a few large firms
dominating each industry. Monopoly capitalism is the dominant character of
economic life in the U.S.A.
Black
people are organized into classes, as are all people in a capitalist
society. The small minority of Black businesspeople constitute the
capitalist class, while the vast majority of Black people are
wage-salaried workers. The Black capitalist is usually a competitive
capitalist, and made to appear insignificant due to the gigantic size of
the monopoly corporations. However, the objective condition is that some
Black people have large enough businesses to hire and exploit five to
seven hundred workers. These workers create more wealth than they receive
as wages. The difference is then realized as profit. Being a little Black
capitalist does not alter the situation. The profit motive is still the
driving force of any capitalist, especially since increasing the
exploitation of labor is the basis for increasing profits.
There
is the critical issue of how the capitalists, specifically the monopoly
capitalists, reap super-profits by compounding the exploitation of Black
workers with racism. Racism does two things: (1) it pits the white masses
against Black people because of a perceived threat to their economic
security (and, due to white supremacist propaganda, because of a perceived
threat to their person, children, home, etc.); and (2) it pits the Black
masses against all white people because racism took an almost
"apartheid" form until the 1960s and lingers today for the Black
working class. Black people have less work, less pay for harder work, and
poorer living conditions (education, health, housing, and food). Racism thus pits the two broad masses
of working people against each other.
in the process, the ruling class profits even more by this and gets away
without answering to any charges. |
338 | ||||||||||||||||
The
only solution that can cure the ills of this society - this center of
capitalist system - is a socialist revolution. Our task is to make a
socialist revolution right here in the U.S.A. There can be no solution
under capitalism, although, the bourgeois ruling class will make every
effort to convince us that it is possible. If that doesn't work, it will
encourage correct-sounding socialist ideologies that fall short of
scientific socialism or consciously revise its basic tenets. All
ideologies have a class character - scientific socialism serves the
working class; utopian socialism can easily be used by the ruling class.
Romantic dreams are always preferred over concrete battle plans.
Socialism
is a social-economic formation that is designed to overcome the ills of
capitalism. It results from the internal development of the laws of
capitalist motion. There are three major aspects of the general crisis of
capitalism. 1.
Concentration of capital. An increasingly smaller bourgeois class
appropriates wealth privately - even though wealth is the social product
of larger and larger groups of people. This is the class character of the
crisis in the economy. More and more people get less and less of a share
in the wealth produced. This leads to a degeneration of all aspects of
social life - food, housing, health, education, etc. 2.
Militarization of the state to rule over the masses and maintain order
for the ruling class. This results in foreign wars of aggression (as
in Vietnam and Central America) and in domestic programs (like those of
Nixon, Ford, Carter, and Reagan) for repression against dissent. Political
corruption, surveillance of civilians by the armed forces, police
repression, and capital punishment are all indicators of, this rule by the
state in the interest of the capitalist class. 3.
Intensification of national oppression. The ruling class separates the
Black and white sectors of the working class in order to prevent the
development of a unified and class-conscious, multi-national proletariat.
It does so in part by embracing Black and white race theories that
reassert old 19th -century racist arguments. Other forms of national
oppression include cut-backs in all government services in the Black
community.
|
339 | ||||||||||||||||
The
solution of scientific socialism speaks directly to these three aspects of
the general crisis: 1.
The abolition of private property by which the
reduction and distribution of wealth would be a public ownership
process, centrally planned to systematically provide for the welfare of
all the people. This does not apply to people's personal possessions, but
to the decisive forces of production and distribution. 2.
Dictatorship of the proletariat by which the government apparatus and
all agencies, institutions, and organizations would reflect the interests
of the working class- the rule of the entire proletariat. 3.
National liberation and the right of nations to self-determination
reflects the solution to national oppression possible only under
socialism. All forms of national oppression can be stopped as official
policy because they serve no material interests as they did under
capitalism. A divided proletariat is good for capitalism; a united
proletariat is good for socialism. Lenin summed up the only correct policy
possible:
These
are the basic aspects of scientific socialism for beginning to correct the
ills of capitalism. The struggle for socialism will require a political,
social, cultural, intellectual, and physical struggle before and after the
seizure of power by the working class. Witness what is occurring today in
South Africa and Latin America.
A
minimum program for day-to-day struggle is summed up in the key concepts
of defense, democracy, and development. Black workers must
be defended from the attacks of monopoly capital. By so doing, the
interests of the entire Black community and the entire working class will
be protected. There must be democratic participation of rank-and-file
Black workers inside the trade union movement. This will raise the banner
of democracy for all people in the society who have been denied their
rights by the ruling class. There must be tools of struggle -
organizations that mold the Black working class into a fighting
class-conscious section of the proletariat, and organizations that mold
Black youth into a vital revolutionary force capable of giving concrete
material support to the struggle of Black workers and the struggle for
democratic education. |
340 | ||||||||||||||||
All of this focuses on the Black working class, and represents struggle in
the, interests of Black workers. If the Black workers' struggle moves to a
higher level, there will be an intensification of both working-class
struggle, in general, and the Black liberation struggle, in particular.
Black, workers will fight simultaneously against class exploitation and
national oppression. In summary, Marxism as a social theory and a social movement has played a significant role in Afro-American history. This has included positive and negative contributions. However, we believe that on balance it has mainly provided a basis for the masses of Black people - as Blacks and as working people - to define their problems with great clarity. Further, with Marxism Black people have had a greater revolutionary potential, because in Marxism the fight for Black liberation is linked to the fight for socialism. Marxism contributes to progress and should be understood by all students.
STUDY QUESTIONS 1. What is Marxism? What have been the main theoretical contributions to its development? 2.
What was the Black Belt Nation thesis adopted by the Com- intern? 3. What contributions to Black liberation have been made by the Communist Party? Discuss its weaknesses and strengths. 4.
What can, Marxism contribute to Black liberation? |
341 | ||||||||||||||||
SUPPLEMENTARY
READINGS 1.
William Z. Foster, The Negro People in American History. New York:
International Publishers, 1973 (first published in 1954). 2.
Harry Haywood, Black Bolshevik: Autobiography of an Afro-
American Communist. Chicago: Liberator Press, 1974. 3,
Mark Naison, Communists in Harlem during the Depression. Urbana:
University of Illinois Press, 1983. 4.
Nell Irvin Painter, The Narrative of Hosea Hudson: His Life as a Negro
Communist in the South. Cambridge: Harvard University Press,
1979. 5.
Cedric Robinson, Black Marxism: The Making of the Radical Tradition.
London: Zed Press, 1983. |
342 | ||||||||||||||||
343 |
Contents | Next Chapter |